Design Critique: Giving and Taking Feedback on Websites
This path is for beginner and intermediate designers who want to understand design critique and practise it on real websites. You will learn to explain critique clearly, take feedback calmly, and review live sites for contrast and flow.
7 lessons · 81 min, plus 1 optional (2 min more with the optional lessons)
Beginner
Intermediate
Advanced (not covered)
What you’ll learn
✓Explain what a design critique is and how it differs from personal opinion or praise
✓Receive design feedback without taking it personally and respond to it constructively
✓Review a real website for contrast, flow and responsive behaviour
✓Tell feedback the design needs from feedback it does not, and explain your decisions
✓Apply critique to improve a UI by comparing an original with a redesign
Start here: defines critique and the vocabulary used throughout the rest of the path.
An English lesson for UI/UX designers introducing the purpose of a design critique, how it differs from personal opinion or praise, and vocabulary such as critique, rationale, constructive and objective.
Shows how a facilitated critique turns feedback into clear, actionable next steps.
A preview of a self-paced NN/g course on facilitating design critiques that surface user needs and turn feedback into clear next steps. It is aimed at designers who run critiques or take part in them, and lists about 3.75 hours of content at a beginner to intermediate level.
Adds a mindset for handling criticism, detaching ego from the work before reviewing designs.
A short video offering five Stoic-inspired strategies for handling design criticism, such as detaching ego from work, treating feedback as a chance to improve, and focusing on what you can control. It is aimed at designers who receive critique from clients or colleagues.
Moves to a hands-on website review, focusing on contrast when a site uses a dark colour scheme.
A critique of a computer science student's website that uses a dark colour scheme. It looks at how contrast is managed when colours are reversed and whether the site's text and colours work on a dark background.
Introduces responding to harsh or non-user feedback and explaining design decisions without burnout.
The video covers how designers can respond to design criticism without burnout. It argues that feedback from non-users should not by itself justify design changes, and that explaining design decisions through two-way communication can prevent aggressive feedback.
Shows problems found, a redesign and a side-by-side comparison, so you see feedback being applied.
Walks through a junior UI/UX designer's original interface, a redesign that fixes its problems, and a side-by-side comparison with feedback. Suited to designers who want to see how a critique turns into concrete design changes.
Closes with the hardest review: judging flow and responsive behaviour across desktop and mobile.
A critique of one website's desktop and mobile flow, asking whether its responsive design holds up. It suits designers who already work on web interfaces and want an example of how to evaluate a live site.
For designers who want to talk about their work more clearly with peers, developers and stakeholders. You will learn to listen closely, give and take feedback calmly, and explain design choices in plain language.
For designers ready to move past the basics, this path sharpens grids, hierarchy, colour and concept work, teaches you to critique, and finishes with advanced principles you can apply to your own projects.
For designers and team leads who want feedback, craft and team habits that hold up over time. You will learn to handle critique, run safer feedback sessions and support wellbeing in your team.
For designers who want to judge finished work more sharply. You will review portfolios, websites, products and AI-generated interfaces and give clear, specific feedback on each.