Learning pathDesign Critique

Design Critique: Judging Portfolios and Product UX

For designers who want to judge finished work more sharply. You will review portfolios, websites, products and AI-generated interfaces and give clear, specific feedback on each.

8 lessons · 1 hr 41 min, plus 1 optional (69 min more with the optional lessons)

  1. Beginner (not covered)
  2. Intermediate
  3. Advanced (not covered)

What you’ll learn

  • Review a portfolio or website and name its strengths and weaknesses clearly
  • Judge whether portfolio work would persuade a hiring manager
  • Evaluate a product's UX, interactions and friction points, including AI apps
  • Run a repeatable critique of an AI-generated or AI-assisted interface

Lessons

  1. Mahesh Ravi 11 min Intermediate

    Start here: a short, low-stakes portfolio website review that shows what a design critique looks at.

    A design review of Axel Durand's portfolio website.

  2. A Designer Who Codes 13 min Intermediate

    Adds how layout and flow connect to the code underneath a one-page portfolio site.

    A critique of a web developer's one-page portfolio site, looking at how it works and flows and how the code underneath supports that.

  3. Pierluigi Giglio 13 min Intermediate

    Moves from personal portfolios to a commercial agency site, judged against business goals.

    1-on-1 Design Mentorship with a Lead Designer →.

  4. Jimmy Design 34 min Intermediate

    Adds a full-length portfolio critique that asks whether the work would persuade a hiring manager.

    An honest review of an industrial design portfolio from a recent graduate student at CSU Long Beach, with critique of the work and a question of whether the designer would be hired. It suits designers who want to see how a portfolio is assessed.

  5. Pierluigi Giglio 10 min Intermediate

    Shifts from portfolios to a live AI product, assessing friction, onboarding and everyday usability.

    A lead product designer reviews the UX and interface of ChatGPT, looking at what works, where friction arises, and how interaction patterns affect usability, onboarding and everyday workflows. It also considers product thinking, navigation and conversation design.

  6. Design With Destiny 10 min Intermediate

    Looks past AI features to UX, interactions and animation in a second product review.

    A product designer reviews the Meta Muse AI app, looking past its AI features at its UX, interactions, animations, usability and overall experience. It asks whether the app is a useful AI agent or just another AI app.

  7. Nick Babich 5 min Intermediate

    Introduces AI-assisted critique of screenshots and Figma designs, building on the review habits so far.

    Shows how to use Claude Code to critique product designs, including raw UI screenshots, designs in Figma, and source code. Covers UI, UX, conversion and onboarding critiques, and comparing a design against a reference.

  8. Nick Babich 5 min Intermediate

    Closes with a repeatable four-step process for critiquing AI-generated UI across accessibility to interaction.

    Walks through a four-step critique process for reviewing AI-generated UI in Claude Design, covering accessibility, visual hierarchy, content and interaction design. It is aimed at designers who want more structured feedback than a single review prompt gives.

  9. Human Centred Design United Arab Emirates 69 min Intermediate

    Optional live panel critique of interaction and visual design portfolios for extra practice.

    A recorded portfolio critique night in Dubai where panelists review interaction and visual design portfolios live, preceded by a talk on presenting work and giving feedback. It is aimed at product designers preparing portfolios.

Keep going

Want an easier start? Design Critique: Giving and Taking Feedback on Websites

All paths in Design Critique

All paths
  • Learning pathBeginner → IntermediateDesign Communication

    Design Communication: Listening and Explaining Design

    For designers who want to talk about their work more clearly with peers, developers and stakeholders. You will learn to listen closely, give and take feedback calmly, and explain design choices in plain language.

    9 lessons · 1 hr 49 min, plus 1 optional

  • Learning pathIntermediate → AdvancedGraphic Design

    Graphic Design: Grids, Colour and Critique

    For designers ready to move past the basics, this path sharpens grids, hierarchy, colour and concept work, teaches you to critique, and finishes with advanced principles you can apply to your own projects.

    9 lessons · 2 hr 57 min, plus 1 optional

  • Learning pathIntermediateDesign Culture

    Building a Healthy Design Culture

    For designers and team leads who want feedback, craft and team habits that hold up over time. You will learn to handle critique, run safer feedback sessions and support wellbeing in your team.

    4 lessons · 84 min, plus 1 optional

  • Learning pathIntermediateDesign Critique

    Running Effective Design Critiques With Your Team

    For designers and design leads who want to run or join critiques, including remote ones, that produce useful feedback rather than awkward silence. By the end you will be able to set up and lead sessions with clear structure.

    6 lessons · 3 hr 24 min, plus 1 optional

Search and sort within Design Critique: Judging Portfolios and Product UX

Sign in to mark lessons complete and see how far through you are.